🥃 Whisky Auctioneer

Рынок Цена↔рейтинг

← к списку

100 Proof Edition Secret Orkney 14 yo
Лот #4585987 · 57.1% · 70 cl · дистилляция 2010 · розлив 4 апреля 2024
⏱ закрытие 25 July 2026 в 21:15 CEST (21:15 Highland N-W)
49
ценность
рейтинг 86.1 (269 оц.) × цена €40 (медиана продаж)

Лот на аукционе ↗ · История ↗ · Whiskybase ↗ · сверено: по EAN (найдено поиском)

Одинаковые бутылки (7 шт, группа AKK): #4585975 (€31) · #4585981 (€35) · #4585996 (€25) · #4585999 (€25) · #4586005 (€28) · #4600810 (€25)

Сверка матча с Whiskybase сверено: по EAN (найдено поиском)
лот аукциона
100 Proof Edition Secret Orkney 14yo
57.1% · 70cl
↔
Whiskybase · рейтинг 86.1
Secret Orkney 2010 SV
Сравни фото и данные глазами (фото ВБ — по ссылке на карточку). Если это разные бутылки — сними матч.
Текущая ставка€34 ниже 3 из 3 ориентиров
Недавние продажи (3 мес) €40 +15% мин €35 · 12 прод. · в сегодняшних €
Мин. розница (WB)€75 +55%
Рейтинг WB86.1 269 оценок
Справедливая цена за рейтинг €86 типичная ниже на 54% кривая рынка
Медиана оценок 86.0 у экспертов 86.0 (31) · разброс ±3.1 · 65–92 · 75 оценок
Вкусоароматический профиль
Dried Fruit 9 Honey 9 Chocolate 8 Sherried 8 Hay-like 4 Smokey 4 Vanilla 4 Fresh Fruit 3 Leathery 3 Malt Extract 3 Nutty 3 Fragant 2 Old Wood 2 Plastic 2 Tobacco 2 Oily 1 Rubbery 1
История продаж этой бутылки
АукционРезультат
2026-07€40
2026-07€39
2026-07€36
2026-07€35
2026-07€37
ещё 24 продаж…
2026-07€40
2026-07€45
2026-07€40
2026-07€35
2026-07€42
2026-07€47
2026-04€42
2026-03€46
2026-02€61
2026-01€48
2025-12€37
2025-12€43
2025-11€67
2025-08€46
2025-06€55
2025-06€47
2025-03€68
2025-02€46
2025-01€41
2024-11€63
2024-09€95
2024-09€58
2024-07€43
2024-07€53
Цены в магазинах (Whiskybase)
МагазинЦена≈€
None auction — None—
Whisky'z shop 75.00 EUR€75
Whiskybase Member market 75.00 EUR€75
Отзывы (по убыванию авторитета автора)
Суммаризация отзывов
Хересно-бурбонный Highland Park под секретной маркой: солёный, слегка дымный, с сухофруктами, пряностями и явной хересностью. Опытные держатся около 85–86, остальные чуть щедрее (86–88); главное расхождение — из-за серного тона в отдельных образцах и жёсткой горчинки в конце.
развернуть подробно
В аромате — вереск, апельсин, сухофрукты (изюм, курага, вишня), мёд и карамель поверх ореховой хересной основы, лёгкий дровяной или зерновой дым и морская солёность; часть образцов раскрывается медленно и заметно выигрывает от воды. Во вкусе виски выражённо пряный (чёрный перец, имбирь, мускат, чили), с сухим олоросным характером, тёмным шоколадом и какао, орехами, вишней и кожей; послевкусие средней длины, согревающее, с золой, дымом и горчинкой. Хвалят баланс, солёность, узнаваемый профиль Highland Park и исключительное соотношение цена/качество для 14-летнего виски крепости 57,1% без охлаждённой фильтрации; критикуют молодоватость и спиртовую резкость без воды, а также чрезмерную сухость и горечь (зелёный грецкий орех) в конце. Опытные ревьюеры оценивают сдержаннее и стабильнее — в основном 84–86, отмечая крепкий, но не выдающийся напиток, где происхождение с Оркни угадывается не всегда; отдельные высокие баллы (88–92) идут за баланс, фруктовость и «взрывное» дымно-фруктовое послевкусие. Менее опытные оценивают чуть выше и охотнее подчёркивают ценовую привлекательность, но именно среди них звучит и самая резкая критика: серный тон от прокладки капсулы (оценка 82), тонкий и короткий аромат, избыточная горечь. Разброс невелик и оценки согласованы вокруг 86, а основное расхождение объясняется не столько опытом, сколько разницей между конкретными образцами и бутылками.
Hvdree 85 21 may 2024 10:26 pm
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
JacobaEd 85 14 jun 2024 1:40 pm
KayMeertens 85 10 mar 2025 10:11 pm
Compared to #23, this is the smokier and biscuit-y one.
Нос 84 Apple, a whiff of smoke.
Вкус 87 Tobacco, smoke, apple, biscuit, pepper, a little peach.
Финиш 85 Apple, vanilla biscuits (lange vingers), a little smoke.
Fundramental 84 15 dec 2024 12:26 pm
Solid dram, Orkney origin not recognisable.
90ClubWhisky 84 11 jan 2025 8:31 pm
Amber color. Slight oiliness.
Нос 84 Light sweetness. Caramel. Dried fruit. Raisins. Honey. Red fruit. Cherries. Dark chocolate. Minerality. Very subtle trace of smoke. Pinch of salt. Not very volatile. Pinch of colored pepper. Toffee. The second nose is more volatile. Sweet cocoa comes through.
Вкус 84 Quite spicy. Black pepper. Ginger. Dried fruit. Raisins. Red fruit. Cherries. Dark chocolate. Mon Cheri. Traces of smoke. Minerality. Pinch of salt. Second sip less spicy. Leather. Walnuts.
Финиш 83 Hot at the start. Chili. Black pepper. Ginger. Dark chocolate. Dried fruit. Cocoa. Oak. Red fruit. Cherries. Second sip a little less, but still hot. Medium-length finish.
MaltVader 86 19 jul 2024 7:58 pm
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 86
kbs26 86 16 jun 2024 7:33 pm
нос 86 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
Rien 84 26 jan 2025 11:30 am
нос 84 · вкус 83 · финиш 84
Totoro 86 20 nov 2025 4:59 pm
A very well-rounded whisky. The combination of bright, citrusy ex-bourbon aromas and darker, leathery sherry cask notes makes it particularly interesting. Relatively little smoke, in my opinion. It seems slightly younger on the nose due to light but noticeable yeast notes. Benefits from the addition of water. Not a whisky for over-analysis, but definitely a solid drink.
whiskytornado 85 04 may 2025 9:37 pm
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
dapoinbua 88 25 may 2024 9:24 pm
нос 90 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
Sporx 86 17 jun 2024 11:04 pm
Blind aroma vanilla, sweet, fermented fruits, acidity The taste wood spice, sweet, tobacco, wood spice, pepper, astringent aftertaste Medium length, some pepper, sparkling, sweet, spicy Today's dram from an open large bottle is much less sharp. I think there was something wrong with the first sample from 83 to 86
feolai 86 22 feb 2026 10:59 am
Nose-86; Taste-86; Finish-86.
Izzino 92 23 jun 2024 11:40 pm
Check I write that it is the only drinkable whisky from the set. But there is a tz flight that we had at BWC. Everything that disappointed me in the previous four whiskys is made up for in this one. Beautiful iodine and strove show, Highland Park style starch. And for the money = amazing whisky
valasios 86 01 dec 2024 12:24 pm
нос 86 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
Stanzeflasche 88 06 jul 2024 12:52 am
Fine and grainy smoke, light but very fruity sherry, with juicy grapes, candied quince, dried apricots, vinous touches, but then it's a rosé wine. The peat gives breadth to all that. A drop of water brings out the smoke. Beautiful balance on the finish. Very successful palate, the fruits melt on the tongue, this with just the right dose of pepper. Then the spices rise, clove, cumin, nutmeg. Long and pleasant finish, almost explosive, and which decants slowly, smoky wood, mossy bark, some black berries, it's almost sparkling, macerated fruits, medlars, morello cherries, moist leather. Chasselas grapes. I think this is one of the best products in this range which has become popular among whisky lovers. https://ilikesky2020.blogspot.com/2024/07/secret-orkney-2010-100-proof-edition-15.html
нос 88 · вкус 86 · финиш 89
Ninofdram 88 30 may 2024 12:07 pm
нос 89 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
Derufus 89 26 may 2024 11:19 pm
нос 88 · вкус 90 · финиш 89
glen efze 88 22 aug 2024 9:29 am
Respect - while Signatory's 100 Proof Edition started with bargains, all of which were under 10 years old, this Batch 15 is 14 years old. And secret or not, this is of course Highland Park, so first class. The bottling costs €45.90 in early summer 2024. The distillery's 15-year-old Viking Heart bottling costs almost twice as much and has a measly 44% vol., so it even has to be filtered. Signatory's 57.1 vol. without chill filtration is a completely different story. OK, in addition to 1st Fill Oloroso Butts, Bourbon Hogsheads are also used here. But Highland Park from Bourbon Casks can be really delicious. The color is promising with a dark amber tone.
GJR 84 13 jun 2024 9:08 pm
нос 85 · вкус 83 · финиш 83
Jamie McDubh 85 26 dec 2025 9:53 am
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
Banzai 87 29 aug 2024 8:00 am
нос 87 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
ryju007 86 17 sep 2024 9:44 pm
Нос 87 intense smoke - a bit chemical, dirty wet cloth, sugar sweetness, strawberry milk candies, toffee, a lot of pepper comes through, citrus
Вкус 86 very smoky, delicate sweetness quickly turning into dryness, a bit of chocolate, not sweet toffee, roasted sunflower shells, slightly fruity
Финиш 85 medium length, very warming, bitter, cocoa, ash
Klexx 86 26 may 2024 1:30 am
нос 84 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
Maltkanzlei 82 09 jun 2024 6:23 am
The sulphur in the ignition pad takes away a lot of the Secret Orkney's potential. There are some lovely and typical HP notes, such as honey, light smoke and a good amount of fruit, but 666 keeps coming through. More notes and reviews on Facebook: #Maltkanzlei
Shaggy 88 26 may 2024 8:36 pm
Great smoky sherried Orkney whisky!
2ndSip 86 25 may 2024 11:20 am
Much better with water than pure. [86 - 82 = good whisky -> get (a second) bottle? Maybe...] Based on price-performance alone, it should get a few more points, but in terms of aromas, it's "only" good overall, it's too bitter for my liking at the end.
Нос 88 without water: quite closed, it needs a little time for the aromas to emerge. If it can get some air, you can discover a lot: dark aromas, raisins, ripe apricots, the sweet heather - the HP is clearly recognizable here. The typical orange is also present. Nuts (especially hazelnuts, almonds) are slowly coming through, OK, the Oloroso is getting going. Typical sherry spices and spices (especially black pepper, nutmeg), plus milk chocolate but with a dark chocolate component, the more bitter part comes through more slowly. The sweetness comes through well with honey and caramel as well as the heather, but it is not extremely sweet, rather it maintains a good balance. The alcohol itself is well integrated, but every now and then you notice its increased strength. diluted to approx. 48%: it opens up more, now there are also a few more acidic components, the orange gets a splash of lemon; but it remains in harmony with the sweetness. It now seems more herbal, more floral - the heather stands out. The fruity aromas also come through more clearly. He now seems more lively/younger, but you can still tell that he is 14 years old; in fact, he reminds me a little of "Loyalty of the Wolf", which was also 14 years old. With every minute of more oxygen he gets better.
Вкус 86 immediately diluted to around 48%: fruity, orange is there straight away, spicy, very spicy on the tongue, creamy texture, but wow, it's still spicy... it could use more water. It becomes quite dry, the Oloroso kicks in, the nut aromas push forward, tart note of dark chocolate, but with even more cocoa content, it is already moving towards bitterness (green walnut). 2nd sip: fruity again, sweeter than the first sip, creamier; the spiciness from the barrel is there right away, it is still quite hot, but the tongue could get used to it a bit, but you can now feel it in your throat - it warms you up well; so it is something for autumn or winter.
Финиш 84 oh ha, it lingers for quite a long time; ash smoke comes through slowly and with a delay (noticeable, but not extreme), slightly bitter at the end. Nut aromas, unfortunately also the bitter green walnut, which detracts from the whole experience a little - but you can live with it.
Odinson 87 09 jul 2024 12:58 pm
нос 87 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
MarcinSmm 87 12 jun 2024 10:44 pm
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 88
waldwhisky 84 31 may 2024 4:46 pm
Really brilliant for the price, but ultimately not satisfactory, short and thin in aroma
Bembel 85 13 mar 2025 5:59 pm
Tasting: 09.2024 Sample: 5 cl. Points with added water: 87
Glenrothes1973 86 13 mar 2026 9:42 pm
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 86
LakatosKE 85 29 may 2024 10:24 pm
Нос 85 Sherried, dry, heathery, salty, light meaty, smoked ham, salted chocolate, sea breeze
Вкус 85 Dry sherry, chocolate, spicy, black pepper, chilli, bacon, Feels younger than its actual age with quite a lot of ABV burn Tolerates water very well, that restrains burn quite a lot
Финиш 84 Medium - quite dry, minty, heathery, very light peat smoke, chilli burn Water helps here quite a lot
Alex_Whisky_Corner 87 01 jan 2025 9:53 pm
A beautiful Highland Park from a sherry cask. You immediately get the typical Highland Park notes. The Oloroso and Bourbon casks have also done their job. You immediately notice heather and a little wood smoke on the nose. Then the sherry comes into its own with cherries, oranges and raisins. This is followed by floral notes and vanilla. The taste is very spicy to begin with, but also sweet. Wood smoke, oranges followed by honey, dried fruit and vanilla. The aromas linger in the mouth for a long time. Mainly pepper, nut - chocolate and wood smoke. A super bottling from Signatory Vintage and considering that this is a 14-year-old Highland Park, it is of course a banger for the price. The alcohol is well integrated and there are no off notes. A great whisky, great to drink. I like it a lot.
MaltMonkeyPetro 87 29 aug 2024 7:49 am
StefanKatonaXXL 88 12 aug 2025 11:49 pm
Finally a great whisky with 100 proof series. Straightforward Highland Park style with everything that goes with it + perfect ABV strength! Parade
Peatyjohn 87 06 mar 2025 5:31 pm
Barely sugar sweet, salty bitter a good cask with no sulphur notes . With a few drops water more barley malt with creamy notes , fruity and well balanced with touch of peat. As a Highland Park fan this one hits the mark with value and quality in my opinion.
Casketje 87 03 jun 2024 8:30 pm
A really fine Secret Orkney. Honestly if you can buy this for less than €50 just go for it, I doubt you'll be disappointed for the price. I love the saltiness of the dram, the hints of smoke and in the background even the feintest hints of tropical fruits. I know a lot of people say Highland Park is not what it used to be, but leave it to the independents to try save some of its legacy.
нос 86 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
Mane140486 87 06 dec 2024 8:54 pm
An atypical nose for an HP, lots of spices, it almost seems like a ray, very dirty in the mouth (which for me is a virtue), smoky, coffee, leather, a little alcoholic, medium-short finish.
нос 87 · вкус 88 · финиш 86
whiskypag 87 12 dec 2024 1:59 pm
нос 86 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
MarcelWhiskyPanda 85 18 nov 2024 8:11 pm
cork not very firm color dark amber Sherry bomb! Price is unbeatable and therefore worth buying But you shouldn’t expect a bomb right away A
Нос 84 He has steam Lots of sherry Alcohol super integrated smoke only in the background Red fruits and light peach bookshelf with old books
Вкус 85 Uii it makes room in the mouth and extremely sour but delicious Also peach sherry Subtle smoke noticeable makes it a bit more complex as there is already quite a lot of sherry on it A bit earthy or musty (not negative) Sour/Dry
Финиш 85 Slightly sour notes of sherry remain Chocolate is there at the end Smoke not too strong in the finish Alcohol tingles
Erik1702 85 05 dec 2024 10:38 pm
Nase: Süß, Sauerkirsche, rote Trockenfrüchte, Gewürze, Eiche, Maracuja ••• Geschmack: Süß, Kirsche, Maracuja, Malz, Gewürze, Eiche ••• Abgang: Mittellang, süße Noten, Kirsche, Gewürze und etwas Eiche bleiben. ••• Fazit: In der Nase startet es intensiv. Süße Noten und Sauerkirsche kommen anfangs. Rote Trockenfrüchte, Gewürze und Eiche folgen. Nach einer wirke mischt sich eine Maracuja mit dazu. Der Geschmack geht ebenfalls intensiv los. Süße Noten und eine Mischung aus Kirsche und Maracuja zusammen mit Gewürzen gibt es hier. Eiche ist ebenfalls da. Mit Wasser gefällt er mir besser. Hier kommt im Geschmack dann auch eine leichte Rauch Note dazu, die vorher wahrscheinlich durch den starken Antritt überdeckt wurde. Aber ehr hat schon eine ganz schöne Schärfe mit im Portfolio. Das gefällt mir nicht ganz so gut. Insgesamt sehr Fass betont. Fehlnoten, bis auf die Schärfe, keine. ••• 85-86
SherryPeathead 86 20 apr 2025 6:09 pm
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
BarleyMail 86 05 nov 2025 11:31 pm
sykon 88 04 jul 2025 11:13 pm
I gave the whisky 20 to 25 minutes in the glass beforehand to allow its aromas to develop. I think this whisky offers far more than you would expect from a whisky in this price range. So far, my favorite from Signatory Vintage's 100 Proof Edition is Glen Ord #22. Although this Secret Orkney is slightly ahead.
Нос 88 Forest honey and bitter almonds dominate the nose. In the background, you can detect what HP always refers to as heather. Although I can only identify this with other HP whiskies, as I have no idea what heather smells or tastes like. There are also light hints of lemon peel.
Вкус 88 The taste also has a clearly recognizable HP profile for me. The dominant note for me is a tart grapefruit. The alcohol is very well integrated, so you can experiment with water if you like, but despite the high percentage it is not absolutely necessary.
Финиш 87 The finish is warming and medium-long, with distinct notes of dark chocolate emerging.
FrankDuff 87 25 aug 2024 4:33 pm
Simply good, the concept works here.
hogsheadwhisky 87 16 dec 2024 5:32 pm
You get a really well-aged Highland Park from the sherry cask with all of its classic aromas, like light spicy wood smoke, heather with leather and tobacco. Considering the price, this is an absolute no-brainer for anyone who likes Highland Park.
Los_Noobos 85 19 sep 2025 11:14 pm
I'm very impressed. The HP Original bottlings from their standard range had recently left me rather perplexed and disappointed. Here at Signatoy, however, you get for a comparatively small price what you'd actually expect from the original bottlings. Personally, I prefer (as with all high-proof spirits) to add a little water. This helps to soften a few minor weaknesses, such as the freshness on the nose or the pronounced pepperiness on the palate. It all becomes more palatable without losing much of its character.
Нос 85 First and foremost, there's a certain freshness, likely from the alcohol. Fortunately, this subsides, and immediately afterward, dark fruit sherry notes emerge. I detect fresh garden herbs, though I can't identify them individually. The scent of violets—or perhaps it's the heather often associated with HP. A powdered sugar sweetness. If there's any smoke present, it's very subtle. Surprisingly complex and appealing for this price range.
Вкус 84 Sweet golden honey with a spicy, almost peppery note. Very oily consistency, like still-warm dark chocolate pudding with juicy black cherries.
Финиш 86 Salted caramel, still very sweet. The spices tickle the palate. It becomes cherry-like again, now reminiscent of sour cherries from a jar on dark chocolate. A slight woody bitterness lingers in the back of the throat. Not unpleasant, it adds a touch of depth.
duranadavid 82 29 apr 2026 3:00 pm
scent: harsh, oil, something technical in the background honey, flowers taste: harsh, oily, diesel, sherry At first, diesel, or something technical, then it turns into sweetness
Dani_BIT 87 20 nov 2024 2:36 pm
нос 89 · вкус 86 · финиш 87
irrerelevant 84 15 jul 2025 9:17 pm
oranges, coastal, subtle herbal smoke, sweet and spicy on the palate, peppery to a degree it makes you think of Talisker, the more water you add the more you think of Highland Park
Malthead_GER 84 26 dec 2024 2:04 am
Color: Honey Character / Style: Fruity & Sherry; slightly smoky
nick_wolf1 86 03 dec 2025 4:09 pm
Very solid dram. Rich and bold profile, well matured. |Hefty cask influence, but the HP character can be easily detected. Takes water well. Great value.
DrulyaSipper 88 25 jun 2025 2:01 pm
Give it some time and opens up very well. Honey sweet notes which develops in fruity palate with tobacco and coffee notes, not so sweet. Aftertaste is richer after watering down to 50%, takes away oak bitterness and reveals dried fruits.
RGill 65 13 jun 2025 3:04 pm
Coastal peat, roasted walnut, red fruits. The finish is quite short.
F3lux 86 15 may 2024 11:29 pm
Nose a little restrained Taste sweet and honey then a mixture of dark chocolate and milk chocolate Initially a bit spicy but then pleasant peat smoke Very good plv
Stouby 86 16 sep 2024 9:00 pm
Golden. Nose: Sweetness, caramel, dark fruit, flat. Taste: Sweet, flat, oloroso, dark fruit. Rounded. HWS #10.
MDSpringbank 86 14 aug 2024 10:19 pm
Mirka666 88 14 jun 2024 6:58 pm
Although bourbon barrels are not my favorites, just like PX and Oloroso, I must admit that it is pleasant to sip.... The alcohol does not stand out significantly in the foreground
Retro 87 06 jul 2024 9:34 pm
Нос 86 Wet grass, honey and herbs. Nutty notes.
Вкус 88 Dry oak, hay and herbs back. Alcohol present, but not disturbing. Nuts intense there.
Финиш 87 Come to stay, maybe a hint of salty smoke out the back. Good, intense dram.
kamiln 88 04 jun 2024 11:41 pm
Blind rating Blind from @Paweł Zuchol Nose: Fat and buttery, slightly mineral. Very intense and pleasant. Some hay and stock cubes, cooked meat, green spices. Overall, I find it very umami. Minimal sulfur and minimal basement. Taste: Tart and pleasantly warming, slightly oaky, distinct spices. Finish: Quite long and bittersweet. Umami disappears. Maybe a hint of dried fruit comes through. It's getting so nice and warm and it's probably because of the voltage. I guess: 12yo 58% Bourbon cask and maybe a small amount of rinsed sherry cask The style suits me Campbelltown Rating: 88 - intense, complex and overall solid.
RedRightHands 84 24 jun 2025 1:08 am
Clearerscroll64 85 25 may 2024 12:30 am
PLV cracker!!! A little reserved on the nose at first, but opens up with enough oxygen. Rather smoky for a HP, but makes the whisky very complex for its 14 years. BE SURE to experiment with water, the typical heather will then be accompanied by wonderful fruity notes. Recommended purchase!
нос 89 · вкус 88 · финиш 88
Bas_Visser 80 10 aug 2024 6:00 pm
total taste experience of sherry cask strength is good. smell does not do much but a subtle taste with refined fresh and light taste. creamy taste
нос 60 · вкус 95 · финиш 85
Drammer_Flo 86 03 jan 2026 12:10 pm
A lovely Highland Park – yes, the cask is dominant and somewhat generic in its flavor profile, but the cask and distillate complement each other well, creating a beautiful and, above all, delicious combination. Highly recommended at this price. For me, a very solid 86/100 (7/10).
Нос 85 Fruity and spicy, with more American than European oak. With aeration, fresh aromas emerge (lemon peel, Earl Grey tea), followed by herbs/heather, a hint of smoke, and mineral notes (damp earth). With water, more smoke, forest honey, and sugarcane become apparent. Despite its 57.1% ABV, the alcohol is barely noticeable.
Вкус 89 Sweet, spicy, and fruity with a touch of smoke, plenty of malt, heather, orange marmalade, nuts, and forest honey. Underlying these are hints of hay, salted chocolate, a light maritime note, and a touch of lavender.
Финиш 84 The finish has both dark and fresh notes – on the one hand, milk chocolate, pepper, coffee, oak, leather, tobacco, and heather; on the other, orange peel and ginger. Slightly salty, but with a pleasant sweetness. It lingers relatively long.
Inspector 87 05 jun 2024 6:12 pm
Delicious whisky, fantastic for just under €50. A must buy!
beezeewilbart 85 13 jul 2025 4:05 am
EDIT: The bottle has now been open and well past the shoulders for at least a year. It is better now. Rating updated. Compared with a regular OB, this is better, indeed. Compared with one of the OB single casks, this is mediocre with the taste of sad old wood. (In this case, the single cask is of the same vintage but bottled at 11yo and, yes, 2.5 times more expensive. But I would rather have 1 bottle of that than 3, 4, 5 bottles of this one. Alas instead I have one of this and none of that.)
Teefinest 86 30 may 2024 2:50 pm
An Orkney whisky from the wild side and that's not just because of the "100 proof", but also with a little water there's still a lot of smoke and power. More than I'm used to in Orkney. But the fruit notes are not lost and remain beautifully present. It has a nice acidity at the back, which provides a good counterbalance to the slightly smoky note. A thoroughly complex and successful whisky.
Нос 87 Green apple, sour apple rings, flowery, honey, lemon, slight smoke, barnyard, fresh
Вкус 85 Raisins, apple, honey, more smoke then I got on the nose,
Финиш 86 Long, powerful and spicy
RRRoman 86 16 may 2025 12:25 pm
Price-quality ratio, I'm on the fence about whether to buy a bottle.
Нос 85
Вкус 87 87
Финиш 86
GlenMinion 85 07 jun 2024 9:13 pm
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
Stefan_Neumair 86 15 jul 2026 7:24 pm
Smells like burnt heather. The taste is reminiscent of a cream made from Oloroso sherry, heather and heather honey, and wood. This Highland Park is quite purist and not too sweet. The casks play a supporting role. It's not particularly complex, but it perfectly conveys the distillery's character. That's exactly what Highland Park is all about. Diluting it isn't worth it; the nose becomes more revealing, but the flavor loses a lot of intensity.
Marcel_Klotzsche 91 14 jun 2024 10:45 pm
Great value for money. I have to say that for the money I haven't had a single Scotch this good in my glass in recent years. For what it is, it's outstanding in my opinion.
Robert_Noot 92 10 aug 2024 5:58 pm
man man man
Нос 85 man man man
Вкус 94
Финиш 97
Bibe_Cum_Gaudio 86 25 may 2024 3:17 pm
In a direct comparison of 100 Proof Secret Orkney, Whitlaw 2024 10y and 100 Proof Caol Ila 10y rum, the Secret Orkney was something of a winner. The extra percentage gave it a slight lead over the Whitlaw, which is a bit more solid. The Caol Ila is not bad, but a bit too bitter and is nowhere near as good as the Caol Ila 100 proof #10. The Secret Orkney 2010 SV has no off notes, convinces with delicious heather and orange notes and with a power that can be channeled with a drop of water. I'm excited to see how the whisky develops with additional air. With the Caol Ila 8y 100 proof #10, this contributed enormously to the development.
sajson 88 13 dec 2024 5:30 pm
Bought this along with the cask strenght Highland Park. What s difference. HP cask strenght is much younger with less cask impact. Less sherry caskd too. No real HP character. This secret orkney on the other hand is what highland park tasted like a decade ago and should taste like in official bottlings. Highly revommended. Best HP I have tasted for 10+ years.