Отзывы (по убыванию авторитета автора)
Суммаризация отзывов
Старый итальянский розлив 80-х: мягкий, маслянистый, с тропическими фруктами и приглушённым торфом вместо йодистой резкости современных версий. Почти все хвалят элегантность и баланс; спорят лишь о том, «легенда» это или крепкий, но обычный виски.
развернуть подробно
В аромате преобладают спелые и тропические фрукты — манго, гуава, личи, — дополненные восковой минеральностью, орехами (кунжутное масло, арахис), ванилью, лёгкой цветочностью и морскими нотами; торф здесь сдержанный, а знаменитая йодистая медицинскость отступает на задний план. Вкус маслянистый и кремовый, на удивление плотный для 43%: сладко-кислый всплеск тропических фруктов, солёно-минеральная сердцевина, лёгкая дымность и пряности; с водой проступают хересная сладость и ореховость. Послевкусие у большинства среднее, с долгим фруктовым шлейфом, иногда слегка горчащее и теряющее насыщенность с годами. Хвалят прежде всего баланс, элегантность и непохожесть на прямолинейный современный Laphroaig 10.
Опытные ревьюеры единодушны и ставят стабильно высоко (90–92), отмечая тонкую медицинскость и фруктовость той эпохи, хотя один счёл розлив крепким, но заурядным «корпоративным» продуктом, ожидая большего от виски 80-х. Оценки остальных чуть шире по разбросу: множество восторженных 91–94 («материал для богов», один из лучших виски в жизни) соседствуют с редкими низкими — 83 за слабый, невыразительный образец (возможно, испорченная бутылка) и 87 у тех, кого профиль скорее заинтриговал, чем впечатлил. В целом согласованность высокая: расхождения касаются не характера напитка, а лишь того, тянет ли он на легенду или просто на добротную старую классику.
I like this, I like this a lot, it has a nice creamy mouthfeel with the peat, hints of brine and possibly iodine but it is the stewed fruits like plum, green gooseberry and perhaps fig. The peat is mixed with some nice spice and it lurks in the background behind the fruit but as the fruit dissipates the peat comes out, not in your face peat and spice, quite subtle actually but the best part is the finish, it just lingers on lovely sweet peat. The balance here is excellent. Perfect Islay whisky for me, perhaps just looses it a little in the middle but that would be nitpicking for the sake of it. This is a world away from the in your face and blunt trauma of Laphy 10 bottlings now.
нос 91 · вкус 92 · финиш 93
21 22 21 22 86 A good solid corporate identity, but I clearly expected more from a whisky from the 1980s!
Brilliant old laphroaig, the subtle medicinal laphroaig notes but also all the fruits from that era, delicious
нос 90 · вкус 90 · финиш 89
нос 93 · вкус 92 · финиш 92
Nose: fruity-oily, peaty and sweet-fruity and nutty notes. Taste: rich, oily, medicinal-sweet-fruity. The aftertaste is quite long, spicy and fruity. 23-22-22-23
нос 90 · вкус 90 · финиш 89
нос 88 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
Soft, light, intelligent, this whisky is made for leisurely consumption among gentlemen. Tones of fruit jam combine with a light touch of smoke, sea cucumber, iodine and salt.
нос 91 · вкус 90 · финиш 90
It's a shame that things like this don't exist anymore. Material fit for the gods. 91-100 – Whisky heaven, best stuff
| Нос |
94 |
An incredible nose for a 10-year-old. Perfect fruitiness, subtle 70s aromas, light peat. Heavenly. |
| Вкус |
94 |
Aromatic, fruity, well-rounded. Perfect balance with the peat. |
| Финиш |
90 |
Light fruit, light peat. Some passion fruit develops over time. Medium length. Slightly bitter later. |
| Нос |
90 |
Exotic fruits that you wouldn’t find in the latest Laphroaig. Sour lychee, loquats, Kyoho grapes, Asian pears, Indian jujubes, lap cheong (Cantonese sausage that’s usually made with wine) and Apple Danish. Cedar alongside very faint smokiness and Orin apple peels. Smelt more smokier after a sip. Mango and incense from the emptied glass. |
| Вкус |
91 |
Apple juice with mango bits, iced black tea, lychee, longans and some iced green tea with honey joined a moment later. Nectar was around my mouth with a touch of grape skin and white pepper. |
| Финиш |
89 |
Green tea with honey that's slightly bitter. Loquats, watermelon, peach core, a little bit of coconut, caramel cookies and some cherries. Thin smoke from the construction site in the background. |
Those older batches are less peaty but more fruity and floral.
One of the best whiskys I've ever tasted! At the Whisky DeLuxe Fair in Berlin 2023 I had this opportunity at an almost bearable price.
| Нос |
94 |
Very fruity, dark fruits, blackberry, black currant, no peat, no iodine. Floral and sweet. |
| Вкус |
96 |
As in the nose. Dark fruity, blackberry, black currant and jam. Light vanilla. No peat on the palate either, some fine campfire smoke. |
| Финиш |
92 |
Medium to long aftertaste, fruitiness stays for quite a long time. |
нос 92 · вкус 92 · финиш 91
It's very complicated It tastes completely different from the current one The main feeling is the savory taste of grain and the mushy wood scent of old wooden buildings Citrus with elegant sweetness and tangerine peel peel oil Old Bottle's distinctive newspaper feel Towards the end, it is finished with newspaper ink and charcoal scent that you can feel the next morning after already burning it the day before
нос 86 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
Overall, a recognizable Laphroaig, but without the abundance of medicinal notes. Great nose, good balance. Cool old-school drinking whisky. Of course, you should drink this in large sips for pleasure. At today's price, it makes no sense other than a beautiful bottle on the shelf
| Нос |
89 |
The gentle salty smoke of a campfire near the ocean. Iodine, seaweed, smoked fish. Walnuts in a peppercorn with prunes and dried pears |
| Вкус |
87 |
Dry wood with iodine, a drop of oil with black pepper |
| Финиш |
88 |
Dry, apple with iodine, dried bananas with spices |
It has an oily viscosity and its bouquet is highly intense. I detect aromas of pleasant, maritime peat smoke, vanilla, crème brûlée, pipe tobacco, leather, citrus, nuts, tropical fruits, chocolate, raisin syrup, and herbs. Moderately complex. On the palate, it has a good balance between sweetness and dryness. The alcohol is well integrated and has a substantial body.
нос 88 · вкус 82 · финиш 89
нос 89 · вкус 87 · финиш 87
Score for a Cinzano bottle from 1980 and a Cinzano bottle from around 1975. Both scored 92 points
Laphroaig unblended 1987 Cinzano imp cork stopper version scbp-6532, a very standard 70s Laphroaig, has an advantage in taste and texture compared to some versions. An old Solvay with a strong sweetness and a peaty flavor.
| Нос |
92 |
Fermented fermented wine with oxidative smell, sherry can be detected, mineral, peat is lighter, sea salt. In addition to the smell of the old bottle, it has a lot of sugar, and the flavors of rotten sweet jam, jackfruit, and dried papaya are outstanding. 92 |
| Вкус |
90 |
Compared with the calibration, the degree of taste is higher, and the concentration of flavor is stronger than that of the same type. The older peat, like the style of the 70s, has strong caramel, with candied orange, mint, red bean paste, and dried bitter orange as the central axis, while aloe vera, sea salt, wood, and spices are all present. 90 |
| Финиш |
88 |
Jujube and bean paste, slightly bitter, licorice is very strong, more delicate and relaxed. 88 |
Tasted from a sample. A lovely old thing. The nose and palate are elegant, waxy and fruity, and while the finish does lose some intensity after all these years, it’s very good overall.
| Нос |
91 |
Excellent old-style nose, with a complex profile. Typical of the era, with a waxy-mineral maltiness and tart tropical fruits, but Laphroaig adds additional layers of oils, nuts and maritime notes. It’s surprisingly nutty actually, with warm sesame oil and peanuts. There’s tar, putty and candlewax, chalk and oysters with lemon on the side. Add green melon and guava. A sooty fireplace, crackling away. |
| Вкус |
92 |
Mild OBF, softly waxy texture, medium weight. Lovely old malt notes, very similar to the nose in its mix of fruit, nuts, oils and a plethora of maritime-mineral notes. Very soft and elegant, starting with a sweet and sour burst of tropical fruits, then drying out in a well-structured development towards wet shingle, seaweed, oysters and menthol. |
| Финиш |
89 |
Medium length, with a lingering tropical fruitiness. |
| Нос |
92 |
Herbs, dried mango, fig, smoke, cloves, nutmeg, green apple; the milky notes intensify in the cup, with hints of peach, caramel, and very faint grape and elderberry. A deeper sniff reveals dry malt. |
| Вкус |
91 |
Soft and light, with a slight oiliness, it begins with a rich, refreshing fruit juice, interspersed with dried figs. Chewing on it reveals the herbal notes of cloves, with a hint of minerality. The later stages have a salty taste, but it's not quite a seawater flavor, and there's also a touch of dried fruit. |
| Финиш |
91 |
The lingering aroma of dried fruit, smokiness, and a subtle milky flavor, reminiscent of a campfire. |
| Нос |
93 |
Superb nose on all sorts of compoted fruits. Tropical of course but even red fruits. Some damp wood and very little smoke. Smells really old. |
| Вкус |
90 |
The lack of power is felt a little more here. Otherwise it's pretty much the same as the nose with the smoke still very discreet. |
| Финиш |
91 |
Becomes very juicy towards the end with the tropical fruits asserting themselves over all the rest. Grandiose! |
The rich flavor reminds me of Springbank from the Japanese market in the 1980s.
нос 92 · вкус 91 · финиш 91
Like a creamy mango popsicle dipped in the sea.
| Нос |
91 |
Lots of fruit, both light and dark fruits, although the lighter exotic fruits predominate, mineral, old railway tracks, chocolate, nougat, very subtle medicinal Laphroaig notes. |
| Вкус |
91 |
For the 43% creamy, fruity start, I also find light and dark fruits, light mineral notes with pebbles and a touch of sea surf. |
| Финиш |
90 |
For 43% ABV, it's very intense with a mix of fruitiness and minerality. A slight bitterness is also present. A great dram. |
N is the taste of Islay that I like, floral, light fruity, honey, berries, a little hospital, and a little star anise at the end The entrance of T is slightly sweet, with a touch of peat, floral, and normal fruit flavor. The latter is more inclined to grass, and the whole process has a smoke flavor. F is medium and short, grass, and the bitterness of cinnamon I really like, the taste is indeed a little monotonous, and the alcohol content is not high
нос 92 · вкус 89 · финиш 88
A lower rating again from my side. Based on a shared sample 2013. This was pretty weak in all aspects. Did the bottle maturation wipe out some of the awaited flavors? Not sure what happened exactly but this 10cl sample was not worth the money. I tased a CS bacth 004 afterwards and found this so much more delightful and rich. 83P in my books. Maybe there are much better bottles of this?
this 80s Italian bottling Laphroaig very diffrent from Laphroaig bottlings nowadays. more fruits, and lower peat. and wonderfuly drinkable.
| Нос |
92 |
malty, and sooty, briny peats comes first. but soon, exoic fruits such as mango,guava comes more. also sweet dry fruits , and salty briny comes. great nose and great complex. |
| Вкус |
92 |
as the nose, exotic fruits comes, and some hints of apples too. and hints of salt,slightly hints of smoked salmon... and times goes, its gets grassier and gets some citrus too. creamy texture and good valanced. |
| Финиш |
91 |
some soot, smoke, quiet herbs, dried fruits, hints of white pepper. medium long. |
Are older bottlings of Leapfrog really better? Are old Leapfrog 10 year old really as legendary as been said a million times? I cannot say that for sure about a 1989 bottling (not 'unblended') that I have tried. However, it is a resounding YES for this piece of leapfrog history! On the nose, leapfrog goodness! Floral and vanilla notes presented ever so elegantly. Then baskets of tropical fruits sweep in with smoke and mild hints of medicinal notes in the background. With time and water, intense sherry sweetness and nutty notes rush out. Notes of coconut also develop. Also some hints of citrus. No modern Leapfrog 10 year olds are even close to this. A truly unbeatable nose! On the palate, elegant and ever present with notes of mango, coconut and citrus. Vanilla and oak sweetness then develops with hints of floral notes. Notes of peat smoke and iodine in the background but never intimidating (much less smoke as compared to modern releases of Leapfrog). With water, sherry, nuts and slight hints of raisin. A complex beast! The finish is medium and transitions from floral notes to nutty notes. At 43% abv, this has surpassed my expectations for it in every way. It is interesting to taste Leapfrog 10 by era as to observe the changes in style of it. Having had a fair amount of Leapfrogs myself (Leapfrog is my favourite distillery), I must say this might have been one of the most memorable and enjoyable drams! A masterful style that is lost and no longer produced by the distillery!
Hmm, blindly I would have thought that it was some kind of Benromach, or even Springbank. There's a sort of buttery-yeasty characteristic that I like. And also dried mango, Pu-erh tea, and very delicate, unobtrusive smoke. Delicious, intriguing. It is very different from the modern tens. But I will be frank, I was not stunned.
A soft and delicate Laphroaig. I would love to keep a bottle around and take my time enjoying it.
| Нос |
90 |
Tropical fruits alongside katsuobushi, with mangosteen and a slight acidity that brings passion fruit to mind. It also feels creamy and warm. A slightly herbal aroma keeps pricking the nose. It almost feels like an alcohol prickle, but from an old 43% bottle? It is interesting how the aroma and that nose-prickling sensation arrive together. |
| Вкус |
91 |
Malty, with gentle fruit, and the peat feels rather light. After a sip, a touch of acidity passes through, followed by banana, mangosteen, the umami of katsuobushi, and perhaps a little grapefruit. |
| Финиш |
91 |
Moderately sweet and bittersweet, with a medium finish. Gentle vanilla and a hint of citrus. |
Nose: intense fresh white fruits, oily. Hints of peat with very balanced fruits and sweetness that is rich and complex. Transform to very syrupy sweetness accompanied by rich white fruits to create a very soothing nose. With water, more pronounced sweetness with hints of citrus and acidic profiles that match well with the overall aroma, with nuttiness emerges later in the transformation Palate: Starts off with iodine and medicinal tastes, slowly transform into heavy white fruits and honey with peaty notes in the background. Oily and quite full bodied for a 43% as the dram wraps around the palate and fill the mouth Finish: Long with a fresh Peaty flavor and dry profile, and sherry when with water At 43%, this dram is as complex as it gets. Much like a cask strength whisky but presented in a very elegant way. After trying this beautiful laphroaig, it only leave space for imagination of all those possibilities with cask strength laphroaigs from that era...