Отзывы (по убыванию авторитета автора)
Суммаризация отзывов
Хересно-торфяной Islay-профиль зрелой Lagavulin: расплавленный, отшлифованный торф, мясисто-кожаный херес, соль и цитрус. Оценки плотные (91–96), опытные единодушны в цельности и балансе.
развернуть подробно
В аромате — акациевый и тёмный мёд, сухофрукты (слива, инжир, финик), шоколад, табак и сигарный лист, поверх которых ложится расплавленный маслянистый торф, пепел, кремень, чёрный чай и камфора; морская линия даёт соль, водоросли, йод и лёгкую медицинскую, йодистую ноту, а сверху — красные ягоды (смородина, ежевика) и цедра грейпфрута с апельсином. Вкус маслянистый, кремовый и объёмный: соль, кожа, чёрный чай, лакрица, тёмный шоколад и перечная острота, торфяной дым здесь отшлифован и «омывает» язык, а не рвёт его, как молодая 16-летняя; послевкусие долгое, дымно-пепельное, с горькой смородиной, цедрой и сухим финалом, без агрессии.
Хвалят прежде всего баланс, зрелость и цельность: отшлифованный, интегрированный торф, качественный херес и то, как возраст проявляется лишь спустя минуты в бокале. Опытные ревьюеры почти единодушны (91–93) и подчёркивают безупречность и сложность; расхождение минимально — критика сводится к тому, что напиток требует времени и раскрывается медленно, а один автор отметил, что при всей добротности это не лучшая из пробованных им версий. Остальные оценки чуть шире по разбросу (до 95–96 у восторженных), но общая согласованность высокая: концентрация мнений вокруг 92–93 при отсутствии низких оценок.
Really good on the nose, going little into leafy and herbacious notes on the palate - overall very good
| Нос |
92 |
Acacia honey, dried fruits, plums, figs, dates, chocolate, toasted bread, tobacco, fine peaty and smoky, spices, caramel, sherry, woody, nuts, seabreeze, iodine, little medicinal, also some orchard fruits, apple, peach - very good! |
| Вкус |
91 |
Oily, creamy, caramel, little leafy, dark honey, good sweetness, spices, herbs, smoky, peaty, chocolate, sherry, woody, little meaty, ham and bacon - still good |
| Финиш |
91 |
Medium long, warm, tobacco, dark honey, chocolate, woody, sherry, meaty, peaty, smoky |
I would describe the nose as composed, it hints at many things without revealing the sum of it parts. (just bear with me on that) The palate has vibrant fruit of plum, apple, fig, and dark berry's and the peat is there but it is so refined that it gently washes over your tongue, unlike the regular 16 year old that tries to rip your tongue out. The balance on show is excellent and the sweet spices just add to the overall effect with some sweet orange marmalade.
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 93
great sherried lagavulin, flawless
From one of 522 bottles, most of which were being auctioned by whisky.auction at the time [Feb 2017]. Bottle #1 went for a staggering £7300 link. C: A lovely sherry butt, fabulous from start to finish. Another show highlight - thanks Isabel. Blog Scores an A[-]
Tasted just after # 0016 27 years old. It is here much more melted and complex. The sherry is also more marked. The texture and balance are really to my liking. 92.5
| Нос |
93 |
Superb nose on sherry, melted and peaty. Ash, flint, pebble, oily peat, black tea, tobacco, cigar. Oily leather, seaweed, light iodine side. Then we move on to a defined red fruit, currant, berries, brambles. We finish on medicinal, with a nice dose of camphor, which mixes with a super grapefruit skin. |
| Вкус |
92 |
In the mouth it is also very complex. The peat is melted and defined, with a little embers. Light barbecue, with ash. Black tea, liquorice, camphor, dried aromatic herbs. Lemon, orange, grapefruit peel. Light dry wood, precious. Greasy leather. |
| Финиш |
92 |
Long finish on the barbecue, ash, blackcurrant and redcurrant, citrus zest, camphor. Fresh. |
нос 93 · вкус 92 · финиш 93
| Нос |
96 |
Starts salty and nervous on the nose. Phenol, peat smoke, slightly medicinal, but at the same time juicy sherry tones, moist tobacco, leather, burnt nut shells, some rubber, black olives, slightly fleshy accents, flambéed banana and a hint of pink grapefruit. Absolutely fantastic! With water: juicy sherry, dried fruit, iodine, salt, peat smoke and blood orange. Absolutely top! |
| Вкус |
94 |
Wonderful deep sherry tones, salt, some rubber, shoe polish, metallic reflections, but also dried algae, peat smoke, cigar ash and blackberries. With water: juicy, sherry-toned, salt, smoldering peat smoke and pickled plums. |
| Финиш |
95 |
Very long, sherry-toned and dry. Salted pretzels, dark chocolate, wonderful peat smoke. Top! |
Tasted with the following Lagavulins: 18yo Feis Ile 2016 (88 pts.), Distillery Exclusive 2017 (87), Islay Jazz Festival 2017 (86), Lagavulin 16yo White Horse late 1990s (90), 25yo 1977-2002 (93), and 25yo 2016 "200 years of L. Distillery Managers" (91).
нос 93 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
http://kaypingers-whiskyblog.de/frontend/fullarticle.php?id=253 Color: Amontillado sherry Nose: Fat sherry, which is permeated with powerful leather flavors. Gentle farmy notes with cardboard, peat, pepper and a maritime honey sweetness. Iodine, orange liqueur, ashes, pencil lead as well as caramel and wet earth. Taste: Creamy thick and instantly voluminous. Orange, pepper, maritime salt, iodine and fine oak wood are on the palate. In addition, leather, chocolate, humidor (cigars), again tingling grains of salt and hints of menthol. Fresh and dry to the finish. The sweet honey note runs profoundly with. Notes of cigars and humidor are present throughout. Finish: But still quite long - chocolate, honey, peat, wet coal, iodine, pepper, old ship rope and cardboard, finely dry finish. No monster finish, rather the filigree Lagavulin. Note: This malt takes a lot of time. Also at the finish! At the beginning, the departure is rather short and not very present. After a long breathe he changes completely - then it fits! 92 points (nose: 92 / taste: 93 / finish: 92) Thus, all special bottlings are tasted and evaluated for the 200th anniversary of the Lagavulin distillery. All bottlings were gone through the bank more than just succeeded. The most expensive bottling was not the best and the cheapest not the worst!
нос 92 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
нос 93 · вкус 95 · финиш 94
My favorite laga, the ceiling in my heart
| Нос |
93 |
Smell very solid, very raw peat, or peat in the dirt, mixed with mud, very moist, moist, oily, very oily, bacon, gravy, kerosene wick (wet Kerosene twine), raw tobacco, cigar leaves, wake up a little longer and start to show some of the Sherry flavors (but still not the heavy Sherry), some berries, some old leather; |
| Вкус |
92 |
The entrance is first of earth, tobacco, fruits similar to blueberries, very ancient peat, broth, leather, a small amount of seaweed; the wine has a very comfortable strength, high oiliness, and I think the alcohol sense is very weakened . |
| Финиш |
94 |
On the finish, great, long, chocolate, biscuits, seaweed, some leather goods. Before drinking this, I was really disappointed with the laga sherry. This wine really made me feel the brilliance. The laga in the sherry barrel can have a good height. |
нос 94 · вкус 93 · финиш 92
Classic Lagavulin profile on the nose, with the Sherry cask relatively discrete. Plenty of the trademark crystal clean peat, salty sea air and citrus fruits then, and not too dissimilar to the 2017 Distillery Exclusive bottling; the one I had close to hand to pour a comparator dram. However, with time, softer fruity notes do begin to emerge, alongside some creamy honey and a hint of well-integrated, leathery oak. The age only really shows itself after 10+ minutes in the glass. Beautiful, and very classy. The Sherry cask becomes more evident on the palate (delivering a significant upgrade on the 2017 Distillery Exclusive from the palate onwards), where it provides a wonderful velvety and creamy backdrop, allowing the peat smoke and fruits to warm you up slowly, accompanied by some dark chocolate/cocoa, a hint of chilli peppers and Hebridean sea salt. The finish is very long and softly smoky (not as in-your-face as younger Islay drams tend to be). Here, the added age really makes its mark. An incredibly well-balanced dram then, and a fantastic example of how good older Lagavulin can be. Crazy price, but all for a good cause I guess.
A nicely balanced, round and oaky Lagavulin, with a moderate sherry influence, on honey, fudge and some orange. Very good, but not the best one I have tasted so far.
Smell ---------------------- 93 Flavor--------------------94 End rhyme--------------------92
N tobacco, sour fruit, campfire, soy sauce, ginseng, a little dust, green apple, a little taste of cool oil The mouth is round, slightly oily, dusty, heavy, fur, berries, slightly acidic, tobacco leaves, with a touch of tannins. body, taste F is long, long, tobacco leaves C is rich and layered, the taste that can be expected before drinking, another example of Shirley Laga
нос 92 · вкус 94 · финиш 93