🥃 Whisky Auctioneer

Рынок Цена↔рейтинг

← к списку

Talisker Surge
Лот #4605769 · 45.8% · 70 cl
⏱ закрытие 25 July 2026 в 21:15 CEST (21:15 Highland N-W)
89
ценность
дешевле, чем ~89% виски рейтинга 84.1 (цена €37 — медиана продаж, 317 оц.)
⚡ по ставке сейчас: 91

Лот на аукционе ↗ · История ↗ · Whiskybase ↗ · сверено: по названию и ABV

Сверка матча с Whiskybase сверено: по названию и ABV
лот аукциона
Talisker Surge
45.8% · 70cl
↔
Whiskybase · рейтинг 84.1
Talisker Surge
Talisker
Сравни фото и данные глазами (фото ВБ — по ссылке на карточку). Если это разные бутылки — сними матч.
Текущая ставка€35 на 5% ниже обычной цены (медиана недавних продаж)
Недавние продажи (6 мес) €37 +5% мин €35 · 2 прод. · в сегодняшних €
Мин. розница (WB)€47 +26%
Рейтинг WB84.1 317 оценок
Справедливая цена за рейтинг €68 типичная ниже на 46% кривая рынка
Медиана оценок 84.0 у экспертов 84.0 (18) · разброс ±3.0 · 72–90 · 58 оценок
Вкусоароматический профиль
Vanilla 6 Vegetative 2 New Wood 1 Nutty 1 Plastic 1 Toasted 1
История продаж этой бутылки
АукционРезультат
2026-07€41
2026-01€38
2025-12€35
2025-11€40
2025-05€40
ещё 24 продаж…
2025-04€47
2025-01€38
2024-12€44
2024-04€39
2024-03€42
2024-01€45
2024-01€48
2023-11€39
2023-11€52
2023-10€52
2023-10€46
2023-07€54
2023-07€53
2023-05€49
2023-05€48
2023-05€47
2023-04€59
2023-01€58
2022-12€62
2022-12€58
2022-12€57
2022-11€72
2022-11€67
2022-09€93
Цены в магазинах (Whiskybase)
МагазинЦена≈€
Topdrinks DE shop 47.25 EUR€47
DrankDozijn.nl shop 49.95 EUR€50
Whiskyfass shop 53.88 EUR€54
MustHaveMalts shop 54.45 EUR€54
Onlineshop Helgoland shop 56.90 EUR€57
Отзывы (по убыванию авторитета автора)
Суммаризация отзывов
Бурбонный Talisker без указания возраста: солёно-морской, ванильно-карамельный, с лёгким торфяным дымком и фирменной перечностью, но заметно проще и моложе обычного. Опытные оценивают как крепкий, хоть и завышенный по цене; согласие высокое, разброс — вокруг цены и «облегчённости».
развернуть подробно
В аромате преобладают морская соль и минеральность, цитрус (лимон, лайм), зелёные фрукты — яблоко, груша, банан, — ваниль, карамель и мёд поверх солёно-морской основы, с приглушённым торфяным дымком, травянистыми и сенными оттенками, местами миндалём, кокосом и лёгкой медицинской нотой сланца. Во вкусе — умеренная сладость на карамели, тоффи и ванили против обильной соли, белый и чёрный перец, пряная острота, дымность обугленной бочки, какао и тёмный шоколад, подсушивающая маслянистая текстура. Послевкусие средней длины, тёплое, солёно-перечное, с дымком угасающего костра и дубовой горчинкой — самая узнаваемо-таликеровская часть. Хвалят свежесть, питкость, гладкое встраивание спирта и сочетание сладости обожжённой бочки с дымом; критикуют молодость и «водянистость», травянистую простоту, дубовую и пепельную горечь в финале и почти единодушно — завышенную цену для виски без указания возраста (многие считают Talisker 10 выгоднее). Оценки согласованы: основная масса держится в диапазоне 83–87, крайние мнения редки. Опытные ревьюеры в среднем чуть строже и аналитичнее — среди них и резкое неприятие («трюковый релиз, ниже среднего», 80), и восторг (90), но большинство ставит 84–86, отмечая нетипичный для Talisker бурбонно-сладкий профиль как достоинство с оговоркой о цене. У менее опытных разброс шире (77–90) и больше прямой критики за разбавленность и горечь, однако общий вердикт совпадает: приятный, но переоценённый и облегчённый Talisker.
dram-drinker 84 03 feb 2023 8:46 pm
Definitely drier and more leafy than the regular Talisker
Нос 85 Little peat, smoke, herbs, green fruits, green apple and green banana, honeydew, little leafy
Вкус 84 Punchy, spicy, peppery, little leafy, little sweetness, herbs, hint of peat and smoke, green fruits
Финиш 83 Medium long, warm, spicy, leafy, herbs, peppery
Hvdree 87 10 oct 2022 10:46 pm
нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 87
Dris 85 06 apr 2023 4:53 pm
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
Baanaanaabob 83 24 nov 2022 6:10 pm
Green coastal smoke, pear, apple, honey, vanilla, very basic but does the job
Dre73 86 10 mar 2024 5:56 pm
A very pleasant Talisker. Powerful, subtle peat, spicy, salty, and a lot of sweet and grassy notes. Very good value for money for sure.
Нос 86 Full scent, very fresh acutally. Floral and sweet notes over a salty, maritime base. No pickering alcohol. A subtle peaty edge, vanilla, fake leather, a little grassy, hay.
Вкус 86 Pretty powerful, spicy, pepper, salty, maritime, sweet, vanilla. Grassy notes, hay, some citrus. Even a bit drying mouthfeel.
Финиш 85 More power now, spicy, pepper. Salty and maritime, drying mouthfeel, subtle sweet peaty smoke, grassy again, hay. Medium long finish.
ConvalRen 80 10 oct 2022 8:30 pm
Surge? From the storm and dark storm? What's next, sea spray. A bottle that should be kept as travel retail but is better than the horrendously priced and made malt that is the Neist Point. Whilst the elements of a peated smoked talisker is found, it lacks the core fundamental aspect of a peaty sweet and salty talisker that it is known for. For that, I'd say its more of a gimmick bottling to fit into the lineup. Therefore, I won't divulge deeper into notes and just say its below average at best.
нос 80 · вкус 80 · финиш 79
JNuyts 84 26 sep 2023 9:06 pm
нос 83 · вкус 84 · финиш 85
90ClubWhisky 85 02 jul 2025 12:03 am
Golden color. Slight oiliness.
Нос 84 Sea salt. Minerality. Citrus. Salted lemons and limes. Spices. White pepper. Delicate spiciness. Still a lot of minerality. After a while, the herbalism comes out.
Вкус 86 There is a bit of sweetness and a lot of salt. Vanilla. Caramel. Sea salt. Minerality. Salty caramel. Toffee. Fudge. Lots of salt all the time. A pinch of spice. Black and white pepper. Quite oily structure. Strongly burnt barrel. Cocoa.
Финиш 85 Minerality. Sea salt. Citrus. Salted lemons and limes. Vanilla. Caramel. Toffee. Fudge, but of course everything with the addition of sea salt. Oak. Cocoa. Dark chocolate. A trace of almonds. A pinch of spice. Black and white pepper. After the second sip, a delicate spiciness comes out. Medium-long finish.
markjedi1 86 18 jun 2023 10:01 pm
Salted Almonds The Talisker Surge is a relative newcomer of this distillery on Skye, initially only launched as a Travel Retail Exclusive, but now easily available in the market. It is a NAS whisky that has been matured exclusively on former bourbon casks. Admittedly, the nose is different from what I'm used to from Talisker. Soft medicinal and minty notes on the nose, with slate. Almond oil and coconut milk, I kid you not. In the background, the Talisker trinity (salty, peat, pepper) is present, but the sweetness of the bourbon barrels mainly provides vanilla and digestive cookies. This is good, but it takes some getting used to. The arrival is rather soft, but immediately sweet on caramel and toffee, followed by ashes, sea salt and candied ginger, white pepper and citrus fruit. Almonds resurface, but with a salted edge. Even something of cough candy and charred wood. I am very happy with this profile. I really like it and it's something else from Talisker. The finish is pleasantly long, salty and peppery. In that respect, it is very typical Talisker. This is certainly tasty, but the price tag is exaggerated in my (un)humble opinion. I pay around 80 EUR for this. I can buy two bottles of Talisker 10 for that! Thank you for the generous sample, Herman.
thijs100 85 15 feb 2023 2:58 pm
For all my whining about yet another NAS Talisker with little transparency, this is actually a tasty single malt.
Ficelli 85 28 oct 2022 5:23 pm
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 83
ThorstenH 72 27 aug 2022 7:04 pm
Eine nette Talisker Variation. 71-80 – Fine, like to drink by time
Нос 72 Grasses on the beach accompanied by a sweetness of white wine.
Вкус 74 Round in the mouth, hardly any alcohol. The grasses dominate.
Финиш 69 The exit reverses the nose. Sweetness accentuated with grass. medium length
gaboruso 84 02 dec 2024 10:12 pm
нос 85 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
feolai 84 19 feb 2026 9:02 am
Aroma:Initially, aromas of forest berries, crème brûlée, banana split, American cream soda, and the sweet scent of butterscotch emerge. This is followed by the smoky essence of toasted pine nuts and subtle spicy notes, revealing the spirit's robust strength. Palate:The initial taste is gentle, perfectly mirroring the first impressions of the aroma. It is followed by the sweetness of brioche and the flavor of banana toffee, which releases a tropical hint of tinned peaches. After a moment, the true essence of Talisker subtly emerges—a sweet maritime character, fresh ginger, and increasingly prominent notes of oak smoke and peppery spice. Finish:The finish is long and powerful—a spicy warmth intertwined with black pepper notes, gradually enveloped by the smokiness of dying embers on a beach campfire, concluding with a faint hint of toasted marshmallow.
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 83
LeChiffre 86 18 aug 2022 5:22 pm
Typical Talisker. Maritime, sweet, peppery, light smoke. It was badly done in advance, which is certainly due to the price. However, I think it tastes good, only the price is really completely covered. For me it plays in the league up to 50 euros.
P.A.O.K.you_are 84 25 sep 2022 2:10 am
нос 85 · вкус 84 · финиш 84
rolabob 84 28 feb 2023 7:51 pm
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
Stanzeflasche 84 22 feb 2026 2:59 pm
Earthy peat, animal sweat, wet dog, a few discreet coastal notes, iodine pearls, sea air, seaweed, kelp, limestone. Candied apricots, molasses, varnished wood, caramel and milk chocolate, drops of fir honey. On the palate, the caramel is powerful, quince jam, it's slightly watery, dried banana, vanilla, lychee, and the distillery's typical peppery note. A fairly long and powerful finish, charcoal, smoked wood, hazelnuts, Carambar, mint candy, cola. Foam, sea spray. As is often the case with this type of bottling, it is a blend of very young and older whiskies, which means that the whisky oscillates between all the flaws of immaturity, and some more pleasant notes. https://ilikesky2020.blogspot.com/2026/02/talisker-surge.html
нос 84 · вкус 82 · финиш 87
VEF206 83 12 aug 2024 10:32 pm
нос 83 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
MaroFF 86 25 sep 2022 7:27 am
Another great Talisker that gives a lot of freshness, fruit and smoke. Delicate peppery bitterness adds charm. The only thing that can be a little bit of attention is the price. I find it a bit high for a NAS whisky. Nevertheless, I like it very much and I will be tempted to buy a bottle. Perfect as a sip "every day".
Нос 86 delicate, sweet, fruity, red berries, orange peel, raisins, vanilla, light spring onions, green apple
Вкус 85 semi-sweet, peat, undergrowth, young oak, dark chocolate, cherries, currants, ginger, a bit of smoke
Финиш 86 Long, warming, honey bitterness, a lot of smoke, dark chocolate
Lu Cifer 86 16 oct 2024 11:30 am
Нос 86 Campfire smoke, light and yellow fruits, an artificial sweetness. Citrus fruits, slightly maritime, a bit herbal, some tea and pepper. It seems a little youthful.
Вкус 86 Sweet and slightly smoky, soft, pleasant, lightly spicy and fruity. Also somewhat maritime and mineral in taste. This is followed by citrus fruits, light and yellow fruit notes, a touch of oak spice, chocolate, and a hint of coffee. Salt, smoke, and a touch of ash. Delicious.
Финиш 85 Slightly sweet and smoky, pleasantly spicy and a little mineral, herbs, salt, wood notes, some pepper, chocolate, ash, smoke.
tribe 82 14 oct 2022 8:54 pm
Нос 86 Talisker smoke and citrus notes, green apple. Otherwise very clean
Вкус 82 Vanilla but also tart wine, citrus, smoke, some milk chocolate and iron from the jubgen which is somewhat covered by the catch and wood. It's ok but I wouldn't buy it
Финиш 79 Quite briefly, light tropical fruits and some smoke remain
besar 85 24 oct 2022 10:21 am
нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
TomAndIngrid 78 16 apr 2023 3:46 pm
A cheek what is offered at this price. That deducts 2 points. This bottling competes with cheap supermarket whiskys.
Нос 80 Vinous, flat
Вкус 77 aqueous
Финиш 77
whiskydramo 90 27 mar 2023 6:40 pm
Impressive
Нос 90 Very citrusy at the start, orange tarts, condensed milk, apricots, grape jelly bites. The fruitiness was lovely. Light smoke coming from charcoal and was accompanied by Thai milk tea. It's reminiscent of Ledaig 1995.
Вкус 90 A bit weak to start with dried figs and dried orange slices. Banana peel, thyme, crispy kale and if you kept chewing you'd get orange jelly eventually. I like the change.
Финиш 89 Chenpi, monk fruits, sugarcane bagasse, well-cooked water-cress and salt.
Choas 86 10 apr 2024 11:02 pm
The malt doesn't necessarily shine with a lot of complexity, but for me it reflects what Talisker should be. Sweet, creamy, but also smoky and rough. That works very well with this malt, even if I don't think it's very old. The price of €60 is still too high, but I would drink it again.
Нос 87 fruity, some citrus, some banana, traces of smoke, a little rough, floral notes, lemon biscuit, a trace of green peel, some varnish, fresh wood, I find it quite appealing,
Вкус 86 creamy, delicate spice, citrus, vanilla, caramel, then it becomes smokier but also sweeter at the same time, it is creamy and quite drinkable, at the same time it has the chili catch and a rough side when swallowing, it sticks well in the cheeks, a nice contrast,
Финиш 85 Sweet, creamy, vanilla, smoke, a hint of melon peel, the smoke keeps the taste in the cheeks for a long time, at the end some tart oak and light fruits
Comet67 84 26 jan 2023 4:14 pm
нос 83 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
mattheww 83 23 apr 2023 5:25 pm
нос 83 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
d1scostu 86 03 oct 2023 9:15 pm
нос 87 · вкус 85 · финиш 87
kikist 84 19 may 2024 8:21 pm
10 is still better value for money if you ask me... but not bad even i expected more...
Нос 87 lot of caramel, fermented fruits sweetness, hints of artificial fruits, pretty maritime, light roses, fall meadow (mix of dry and green grass), freshly grinded black pepper After time in the glass vanilla notes are developed, mainly vanilla flavored sugar, lightly malty
Вкус 82 bitterness, decent smoke, a little bit of fruitiness, not a lot of Talisker spiciness
Финиш 83 light ash, artificial fruits, herbal, wormwood, hints of spiced rum, coconut, quinces
Tommyknocker 81 01 aug 2023 7:24 pm
The order to the Blender was clear: make me a young, simple Ardbeg without frills. It succeeded, but unfortunately an attempt was made to conceal the youth with a lot of wood. I would be interested to know if Virgin Oak was also at the start.
Нос 85 Brine, lots of vanilla and light fruit, light smoke. Just as you would expect a Talisker from the bourbon cask. No more and no less.
Вкус 82 Peppery beginning, sweetish buttery note. Then very spicy, bready, oaky.
Финиш 75 Quite bitter fresh oak. Unfortunately disappointing.
domani 79 28 jun 2026 12:25 pm
It's difficult for me to describe; there are some components that are clearly recognizable as belonging to a Talisker, but basically it's a 10-inch light version without any noteworthy features. It's good to have tried it, but I don't need it. - June 27, 2026
Нос 78 Peppery nose, slightly smoky, with some local fruit in the background, apple and pear; the smoke intensifies over time and you get a Talisker.
Вкус 81 Smoke, clearly noticeable here, creamy, malty sweetness, pepper, toffee
Финиш 79 Medium-long finish, strong, smoky oak aroma
junyvyao 83 24 jan 2025 10:25 am
нос 83 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
Whisky-Fancier 87 04 sep 2023 9:02 am
A quite tasty and more smoky Talisker than usual. The burned barrels bring an enormous sweetness (grapes) that harmonizes very well with the stronger smoke. Reminds me of a young lagavulin. Very drinkable at alcohol strength.
нос 88 · вкус 88 · финиш 86
Jimbeau 85 01 dec 2022 9:28 pm
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
Wolf68 86 21 jul 2024 4:35 pm
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 87
dercaptain 85 24 jun 2023 1:04 am
Нос 86 Fresh, salty sea air, young, sour wild berries, blueberries, subtle smoke, caramel.
Вкус 85 Sweet blueberries, caramel, vanilla, slight spiciness (Chili Catch?), woody dryness at the end. The smoke is still subtle but envelops everything.
Финиш 83 The finish is unfortunately relatively short and ends in a very woody dry mouth with some bitter chocolate
gossm01 89 05 sep 2022 8:18 pm
It has an oily viscosity and its bouquet is relatively intense. I have aromas of malty sweetness, maritime notes, vanilla, light smoke, caramel and honey sweetness. Not very complex. Relatively dry in taste. The alcohol is well integrated and it has a heavy body.
Bembel 77 20 oct 2022 8:43 am
Tasting: 10/2022 I really like bourbon aging. I would have expected a lot more here... Unfortunately rather below average for a Talisker. A few more years would certainly have made a difference here.
Нос 80 In the first nose a typical Talisker with citrus and salt. Then comes the Holt with lots of vanilla. A very subtle, almost phenolic smoke with a little sweetness lies above it. Later the bourbon cask comes out more. Sweet and sour fruit is present.
Вкус 80 Fresh start. Very cute. A little watery. Then vanilla and slightly flamed wood. Slight bitterness with ash. Short pepper catch.
Финиш 70 Short - medium length. Sweet. woody. A slight acidity resonates at the back.
Phalat 83 05 jun 2023 7:00 pm
Very weak Talisker for this price/value ratio, this whisky is a joke
Нос 85 salty dusty barrel floral... oranges caramel green banana apple chips peppery peat
Вкус 82 salty caramel woody bitternes bloodoranges milky
Финиш 81 bitter smoke ginger milky peppery peat medium long
DrPepper_Addict 83 22 oct 2024 2:26 pm
HunterRomario 88 30 dec 2022 1:38 pm
Alcohol: 45.8% Aroma: Oranges, sweet candies, followed by saltiness, sea, windiness in the second wave, and a bit further on, a sense of comfort. (87b) Taste: There is smoke, but oranges dominate. Then there are apples, lemons. Oily on the tongue. Spicy fruity juiciness. Ashy aftertaste. The oranges, like the candies in the scent, are quite surprising in Talisker, but really why not? (88b) Points: 88/100 Summary: I tasted at our recent sit down with josé and then again from a cast sample over time. An unusual but good Talisker. Unexpectedly fun and playful. My name is Surge, and I am funky...
claymore84 83 17 sep 2022 9:50 pm
Tasted on 09-17-2022.
huangshantong 86 29 jan 2024 2:23 pm
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
face 80 19 sep 2022 5:53 pm
нос 86 · вкус 74 · финиш 79
etwa77 85 24 nov 2022 10:54 pm
had a renewed interest in talisker since i finished a bottle of the distillery’s 18 yo this summer, while vacationing in a small cottage on the Ligurian coast. with friends, vacationing with friends… i mean i didn’t drink it all by myself! too much caramel and coffee in the surge, i’d preferred it closer to bourbon wood, but the peat&salt dna of the distillery on Skye is there and it makes up for a rather pleasant sip.. a little bit too drying in the finish, though.. 85 points if need be. the aromas in the nose are quite negligible.
Steven79 84 26 apr 2025 9:08 am
kofima 84 26 sep 2023 4:33 pm
нос 84 · вкус 84 · финиш 83
Peatyjohn 85 19 may 2026 4:29 pm
I found Surge to be a slightly unusual, middle-ground Talisker, sitting between Neist Point (sweeter, softer) and Distillers Edition (richer, sherried), but not fully satisfying either direction. Nose / palate impression: Dominated by sweet fruit notes—apple, pear, and honey. The profile feels fairly sweet overall, with only a touch of spice underneath. Sherry influence: I can’t really detect sherried character, which makes it feel less deep or layered than expected. Talisker character: This is the key issue for me —it feels like the core Talisker identity is muted or missing, so it doesn’t deliver the coastal, peppery signature that draws you to the brand. Balance: I see it as somewhere between Neist Point and Distillers Edition, but ultimately: * Not as sweet as Neist Point * Not as rich or structured as Distillers Edition * But still too sweet-dominant overall Finish: Light spice, but nothing that restores the missing Talisker edge. ⸻ Overall verdict A somewhat balanced but identity-diluted Talisker where sweetness overrides the coastal/peppery core. Decision: I would not move from a sample to a full bottle.
lingling 86 11 feb 2025 6:20 pm
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 86
the_muskox 77 05 jun 2023 5:56 pm
It’s certainly a Talisker – all the classic character is there. The problem is that this seems to be just an inferior version of the 10. The 10 has a better mouthfeel, more complexity, and a longer finish. If this were cheaper, I’d say that it was a good way to save some money while still accessing a real Talisker profile… but the MSRP on this is $115, so that doesn’t work. In that respect, this seems like one of those duty-free bottlings aimed at non-enthusiasts who jump a new label from a brand they might already like and don’t think twice.
ralle1968 83 06 oct 2022 11:05 pm
Fat bourbon and oak aromas immediately pour out of the bottle when poured into the room. After 16 minutes, the mixture of flavors has settled; soft smoke, roasted apple and stewed pear are added. On the palate it is definitely... oaky, vinous, smoky... and then the Chilicatch dominates. But why little? In the finish there are also chocolate, nuts, some caramel. What are these fruit flavors? Somehow the undifferentiated compote with bitter notes like block chocolate. Somewhat sweet and smoky. So: a nice dram, nothing special; two or three years ago something like this would have been available for 30 euros. As a blend with an Islay touch. PS: The Talisker Surge becomes quite tasty with water.
GlenWim 85 10 sep 2023 11:11 pm
нос 87 · вкус 85 · финиш 83
RickyNY 86 24 apr 2024 10:59 pm
нос 85 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
Schleifreak 84 21 nov 2023 8:22 pm
нос 84 · вкус 86 · финиш 82
aquataste 83 07 mar 2024 9:37 pm
Нос 84 Very fresh, fresh bourbon tones with a sea breeze and delicate smoke, a pinch of pepper, fresh sweet vanilla, caramel and toffee, fresh aromatic wood, green fruits, some fresh dark forest fruits, a breath of fresh herbs, notes of ash in the background
Вкус 84 Fresh bourbon tones with a sea breeze, after a second there is a pinch of ash and black pepper, salt, green fruits (mainly apples) with light citrus, milk chocolate, salted caramel, fresh vanilla, notes of charred wood, a breath of herbs, notes of fresh wood
Финиш 81 Long, warming, fresh bourbon tones with dried herbs and sea breeze, milk chocolate, a pinch of pepper, ash notes
Hupsende Hippie 79 25 jan 2023 1:03 pm
I tasted this in a tasting with only Taliskers, and it was by far the least of the bunch. N: Bourbon barrel aging is unmistakable on the nose, with some apple, vanilla and bread. T: It's metallic, sharp and thin. In other words: I think this is pretty young stuff. The peat is very light, and I get that because this whisky is intended as an 'entry-in' for the global market and beginners. There are also some stone fruits and citrus in the taste, but it is not very special. Conclusion: Skip this one, it's not worth its price at all...
BarrelBeast 82 19 sep 2022 5:54 pm
Youtube Review: https://youtu.be/q_E8OFoeYhA
нос 85 · вкус 78 · финиш 82