Отзывы (по убыванию авторитета автора)
Суммаризация отзывов
Молодой (9 лет) Blair Athol из первой заливки бочки олоросо: очень тёмный, насыщенно хересный, с тёмными фруктами, вишней и шоколадом. Хвалят как отличное соотношение цена–качество, но многие считают его прямолинейным и слишком хересным, а послевкусие — слабым.
развернуть подробно
В аромате — тёплая карамель и жжёный сахар, обилие тёмных и красных фруктов (вишня, слива, черника, изюм в роме), тёмный шоколад, кофе и мокко, орехи, местами лёгкий дымок горелого дерева; алкоголь при крепости 57,1% спрятан хорошо, хотя у части дегустаторов сначала колется в нос. Вкус мощный, сладкий и пряный: тёмный шоколад, вишня вплоть до ассоциаций с вишнёвой колой, сливовое варенье, орехи, чёрный перец, солодка; тело плотное, текстура кремовая, с водой раскрывается больше фруктов и пряности. Послевкусие расходится сильнее всего — у одних длинное, согревающее, с солодкой, кофе и шоколадом, у других короткое, быстро гаснущее, с оттенком марципана, а порой сухое и горьковатое.
Общий разброс оценок узкий (в основном 83–88), и почти все сходятся на превосходном соотношении цена–качество при выпускной цене около 45 евро. Опытные ревьюеры делятся: одни ставят 87–89 за насыщенный фруктово-шоколадный профиль и удачно спрятанный спирт, другие снижают оценку, считая, что бочка полностью подавила тонкость (излишняя хересность «убивает сложность»), вкус становится резким и «грязноватым», а finish не заслуживает упоминания. Заметен и мотив разочарования: при всей эффектной тёмной окраске это самый слабый розлив первой серии, а на фоне множества вышедших позже хересных бомб виски воспринимается как ещё один современный хересный образец без выдающейся глубины — приятный ежедневный глоток для любителей насыщенного хереса, но не откровение, особенно по нынешним завышенным ценам вторичного рынка.
нос 87 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
The nose is exciting, reminds me a bit of Millstone from the Oloroso cask (although the guys from Zuidam manage to get the pleasant, funky dirt in the nose much better), but after that it gets a little dull and the finish isn't worth mentioning. For the issue price of €45, it's OK these days, but I really don't need a whole bottle.
| Нос |
86 |
Hm, I haven't even reached my standard nose distance when nosing yet, and I already have warm caramel with a dash of kirsch in my nose. Add dark chocolate shavings and the Black Forest gateau is almost ready. As the oxygen contact increases, a dirty note reminiscent of sulphur is added. It is not a sulphur note, but the aroma is close to that. Prunes, blueberries, now clearly freshly ground black pepper, smoked paprika spice. |
| Вкус |
84 |
While the beginning was clearly caramelly on the nose, the start on the tongue now has a clear note of hazelnuts and almonds. No trace of caramel anymore, but the cherries are still there, as are the plums, and there are also fat figs. Not too strong when undiluted. Roasted aromas, a hint of peppermint, a little lavender, liquorice. It seems a little chemical at times, but then it catches itself again. |
| Финиш |
80 |
When I have mint or peppermint on my tongue, that is often a sign of a short finish. And that's the case here too: it fades away quite quickly, leaving only a little marzipan and artificial hazelnut flavor. Finito. |
Very pleasant whisky, a lot of red fruits, chocolate, woodsmoke, and certainly a lot of licorice in the finish.
| Нос |
87 |
Very fruity, a bunch of red fruits, berries, cherries, blueberries, prunes, a little smoky note underneath. Hardly any alcohol punch noticeable. Also some chocolate. |
| Вкус |
88 |
Powerful, spicy and fruity, berries, prunes, chocolate, a little whiff of licorice. Full bodied. |
| Финиш |
87 |
Wow, a very lot of licorice sticks now, red fruits, prunes, blackberries, a touchvof woodsmoke, pretty long finish. |
Value for money.
| Нос |
87 |
Mocha, hazelnut and balsamic vinegar. |
| Вкус |
86 |
Prune, hazelnut, mocha and wild cherry. |
| Финиш |
87 |
Mocha, hazelnut, prune and cherry. |
The second BA of 2 in a blind flight of 5 SV100P's. Amazingly, while edition #9 scored highest for me, this edition #3 was rather disappointing. Overly sherried killing a lot of the subtle complexity I discovered in its sibling.
нос 80 · вкус 78 · финиш 79
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
нос 85 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
нос 86 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
The cask reigns supreme, but it was a good cask.
Still really convincing on the nose (fully intense, solid, with a hint of lemon over time), but it becomes very sharp in the mouth and a bit dirty on the finish, which for me results in a rather all-round taste experience. 71-80 – Fine, like to drink by time
нос 86 · вкус 72 · финиш 79
нос 88 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
Aroma Ginger, chocolate, lots of sherry notes, spices The taste Alcohol well integrated, chocolate, wood spice, sherry (pretty wet cask), no real complexity resonance Medium length, spicy, sherry notes, pepper
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 86
As of today, it's from the Proof 100 Series Signatory Vintage series, which I like the most. Once again, I write this as I try a new whisky from this range each time I try it. Beautiful color, literally very deep mahogany mixed with burgundy. You can see that the barrel used for aging was very wet and, most importantly, good. The whisky is very fruity, the sherry overwhelms the senses in every part of the tasting. Hot plum jam with aroma, that's what I like. Also, a lot of dark fruits, black cherries, sweet cherries and lots of chocolate. The finish is very pleasant with fruit and coffee flavors. It is also slightly spicy, which only makes it better, because without this pleasant spiciness it would be too bland. I'm now waiting for her "sister" Edition #9. I'm very curious about the difference between them.
| Нос |
89 |
very intense, sweet, buckwheat honey, flower meadow, lots of sherry, raisins, hot plum jam, chocolate, young oak, wood varnish |
| Вкус |
89 |
sweet, but not like the aroma, freshly planed oak board straight from the carpentry shop, resinous, then dark fruits, black cherries, sweet cherries, grape skin, dark chocolate, spices, a pinch of pepper |
| Финиш |
88 |
long, very warming, with perfectly hidden alcohol, coffee beans, plum jam, chocolate-covered cherries, sultana raisins, candied orange peel. |
Dark first nose, mainly cherry with dark chocolate, slight spice. There's also a lot of chocolate on the tongue, a bit of alcohol spiciness, nice and creamy. With a little water about 55% more fruit, currants, more spice, white pepper without water it is creamier. Nice young sherry-heavy malt, the PLV here is very good and what surprises me is no new style sherry character - 86 points
Still too young, but already too much on tap.
нос 82 · вкус 80 · финиш 81
Because it was one of the first from the 100 proof series it was a pleasant surprise. However, now that so many sherry bombs have come out it falls a bit. Really delicious to drink away but no more wow. Complexity: 86 Intensity: 90 Price quality, TOP.
Signatory has a new series. 100 Proof brings batch bottlings that are reduced to the still impressive strength of 57.1% vol. Naturally un-chill filtered and not colored. The first outturn in the series includes this very dark Blair Athol from the 1st Fill Oloroso Butt. All four whiskies from the first outturn were offered for an RRP of €44.90 - an absolutely fair price that was certainly also meant to be a statement. The Blair Athol disappeared from the shops again quickly. At 9 years old, it is quite young, the color indicates massive barrel influence, which can be difficult with Signatory. But I like Blair Athol and am happy to be able to taste it as a sample. glen-efze.de
нос 84 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
At first the alcohol stings a bit in the nose. Once you're halfway used to it, there's a brutal gummy bear smell. Haribo Happy Cherries. Really a lot of cherry. And a lot of sweetness. Syrupy. Reminds me of a molasses rum in places. For me, water changes very little in the nose. Very powerful on the tongue, despite the addition of water. The cherry is also omnipresent here. It's really like a sip of alcoholic cherry juice. Or Cherry Coke, even more appropriate. The syrupy sweetness from the nose is now a little more subtle. Instead, more spicy notes. Going more towards dark chocolate now. Slightly dirty. Nutty. Without sulfur, however. No youthful notes. The sherry irons this out completely. Very, very barrel-heavy. Delicious. Not overly complex. But not a bore either. Absolutely great value for money. It's great to play with water. And that for 45€...gives you an extra point!
нос 88 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
нос 86 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
Color: dark red to burgundy
| Нос |
88 |
sweet, pleasant, fruity, forest fruits, blueberries, dried plums, burnt sugar, soy sauce, coffee liqueur, walnuts, well-hidden alcohol despite the age of 9 |
| Вкус |
88 |
pleasant sweetness, changes nicely over time from sugar sweetness to sour jellies and finally dark chocolate, unfortunately you can feel the youth slightly but the spiciness is acceptable, confirmation of the nose, there are citrus fruits and the bitterness of the fruit stone |
| Финиш |
89 |
long lasting, sweet, sour, chocolate-coffee, pleasantly warming |
EYE/NOSE Visually, it is a deep brown tone with a slight reddish tint. The nose reveals dark, sweet honey and notes of cough syrup, similar to those in Edradou. Ripe red fruits and a hint of dark chocolate follow. The nose is quite pleasant, if a little boring - typical modern sherry influence. PALATE On the palate, the quality decreases rapidly. Plenty of alcohol and an excessive amount of sherry dominate the Blair Athol. Our test sample seems anything but harmonious and well integrated. Even after several attempts, the mouthfeel can best be described as flat and thin and the malt almost seems a little artificial in taste. FINISH/CONCLUSION The Blair Athol leaves with a bitter and dry aftertaste. The aromas are less well integrated than in the Ardmore and Tullibardine (—> sulphur alert!) from the 100 Proof series, which were released at the same time. Despite the impressive colour, this is the weakest of the first four bottlings for me. The malt is a 'good' example of why you should never judge a whisky solely by its appearance, let alone buy it. More notes and reviews on Facebook: #Maltkanzlei
нос 84 · вкус 82 · финиш 82
Pretty good value for money! Little bit hot in all segments, i guess will be better if bottled at lover abv, but i am thankful for fair price
| Нос |
86 |
Pretty strong burn at first, dried figs, thick sherry, oak, coffee, praline, new leather, smelly socks, berries, lightly metallic |
| Вкус |
83 |
Sweet, dark, chocolate, pretty hot, creamy, oaky |
| Финиш |
81 |
forest fruits, herbal, burning, chocolate, cherry praline, alcohol |
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 87
нос 87 · вкус 87 · финиш 88
A delightful surprise in the glass.. Beautiful and powerful sherry notes and also some smoked wood. In my opinion, another over-the-top (sherry) whisky, but I love this!
I once ordered a bottle for a retail price of 45 euros. For the price, SV is probably offering something with good PLV again. I also find it absolutely modest and selfless that some people here give 92 points and offer the whisky for sale at the same time. In any case, I wouldn't do that with such "hot" stuff. Great ;-)
Sorry guys, but I don’t understand all this hype. It’s not bad, especially at current price points, but nothing special, just another one modern sherried whisky without something extraordinary
нос 85 · вкус 85 · финиш 85
The taste and price are quite convincing. The price-performance ratio is right for me, but it wouldn't be worth much more than that.
| Нос |
87 |
Quite dark fruity and intense on the nose. Seems somewhat understated. A somewhat sweet aroma rises from the glass, raisins marinated in rum, Amarena cherries, strawberries, plum jam, all a great dark fruit mix. Also has a light red wine note. There are also roasted aromas of roasted almonds, coffee beans, tobacco. |
| Вкус |
86 |
Slightly peppery and spicy on the palate. Provides a tingling mouthfeel, slightly warming in the mouth. The sweetness of chocolate, toffee and honey spreads. The fruitiness of dark fruits and dried fruit is also present on the palate. More sherry-intensive, |
| Финиш |
84 |
Short to medium finish, nuts, cocoa, mocha, some spicy pipe tobacco, wood, |
Despite the fact that I'm from Columbia, I would like to apologize for Polish flippers :(
нос 89 · вкус 85 · финиш 81
The number 3 of the 100 Proof series from Signatory Vintage. A Blair Athol who has 9 years on his back. The color is very dark, which is reflected in the notes. A lot of dark sherry hits the nose as well as the taste. Very charged, of course, but I like it. The alcohol is very well integrated and considering the PLV, you can't go wrong here. Great whisky.
An absolute hype whisky because of the color, but funnily enough it's the weakest in the series.
нос 82 · вкус 81 · финиш 82
Powerful, juicy, surprisingly quite sweet, prunes with raisins in dark chocolate sauce stand out, plus slightly burnt caramel, nuts, smells inviting. But no aroma miracle. In the mouth it reflects the nose, although the aromas seem a little more muted. A little black pepper is also added. The % fit really well. The aromas remain true to themselves in the finish. Stingles a bit at the front of the tongue. It's just the right daily dram for those who like a lot of sherry in Scotch. A top whisky for the RRP, everything fits together perfectly. But it doesn't do justice to the current 2nd market prices, there are certainly more diverse options out there.
For the RRP up to €44.90 it is a decent whisky. But you can clearly notice the wet barrel and the alcohol on the palate. I wouldn't pay twice as much for the whisky.
| Нос |
87 |
Nougat and dark chocolate. Christmas spices and gingerbread. Plums, ripe cherries. Nuts. Freshly ground coffee. Sherry. |
| Вкус |
81 |
Peppery, sharp start. Still spicy even with a little water. Something burns on the tongue. Gingerbread. Nuts. Black coffee. Ripe, dark fruits. Dark chocolate. The alcohol gives it oomph, but it's not well integrated. The aromas seem artificial, not deep, which suggests a wet barrel. Cough Syrup. Oak spice, bitter. |
| Финиш |
81 |
Pepper, oak spice. Bitter chocolate. Short to medium length at best. |
нос 86 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
нос 88 · вкус 90 · финиш 88
Interesting how the Polish friends (who of course have a whole bunch of the bottles) awarded 92 points... A good Blair Athol, slightly spicy, a little oily - but no more than 83 WB because nothing special.
нос 88 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
2024-02-07
| Нос |
82 |
Coffee, cherry, Black Forest cherry, sherry!!!, herbs, little mustiness, no nuttiness, Mon Cheri, cherry liqueur |
| Вкус |
83 |
Cherry juice and dark chocolate, no strong alcohol note |
| Финиш |
83 |
dry and bitter |
Sniff: Black cherries, big sherry and plums. A LOT of cherries, cola and some dark, wet oak. Sip: Quite a bit more oak on the arrival, but it gets honeyed and waxy fast. There's cola, cherries, a bit of chili and a slightly rubbery texture. Swallow: Very dry, but not incredibly rich. It's more mellow than I expected. Roasted nuts, barley and wood. Again, cherry, cola, Dr. Pepper.
нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 86
I got a sample of this and a SV100 proof Ardmore in 2023 when I first became aware of the series and, at the time, neither of them went down very well. The sherry cask was too much for me and both felt like they were drowned in it, blocking just about all the distillery character. Over the last few years, I’ve kept circling back after learning from experience that bolshy wine and oak tannins calm down over time, and it’s been worth my while to check in perdically with bottles that start out too far in that direction. This Blair Athol has been a great example of that, but in addition, I seem to be getting on with this profile at the moment. Sometimes it takes ages for things to come together. As regularly remarked, whisky as a hobby really does reward patience.
| Нос |
85 |
Plum brandy, juicy raisin, black cherry, and cola with dark malt loaf lurking in the shadows next to damp wood. On the brighter end there was a surprising amount of vanilla developing out of coconut-marzipan and sweet fragrant basil turned the fruit into purple cough sweets |
| Вкус |
86 |
Buttery blackberry and forest fruit crumble with toasted brown sugars and syrupy ginger get a rich and boozy boost of creme de mûre coffee liqueur, and chocolate mirror cake |
| Финиш |
82 |
Cranberry sauce leans into dark oak and some wine tannins, more cocoa and coffee liqueur but the basil-anise returns, as does the sweetness leaving a cocktail of southern sweet tea and sambuca. Which I don’t hate. |
нос 87 · вкус 87 · финиш 86
Blind sample courtesy of Lunatica. Well, I was able to pinpoint the answer but that's because I knew he sent me this among others. Otherwise I would have never guessed it. With the preconception of what it is I can maybe taste a hint of the underlying malt, but it's the wood that does all the heavy lifting here. Very much Signatory's brand of sherry malt. Quite nutty and chocolatey, albeit a bit bitey. Pretty enjoyable "sherry bomb" (read: wood bomb) for an affordable price, I guess. For me a bit too tannic and bitter to grant higher score. Closer to 86 than 88.
Nose: sweet, cherry, spices, oak, some orange, a little vanilla, marzipan ••• Taste: sweet, cherry, oak, some spices, slightly musty wood ••• Finish: medium long, cherry and oak remain. ••• Conclusion: An important whisky. There is a full load of cherry jam on the nose. It has a very sweet taste. Cherry and oak dominate. A highly charged whisky. There is very little left of Blair Athol. If you like cask-heavy sweet whisky, this is the place for you. I like him. The alcohol gives him a lot of strength but is quite well integrated. The complexity is manageable for 9 years.
How on earth does Signatory still have this A-quality sherry casks? Impressive. This Blair Athol could be a future classic, when stowed away for 20 years in a dark cellar. Of the non-peated expressions, this is hands down the best offering. Full review on https://whisky-odyssey.com/nl/TASTING-NOTES/Signatory-100-Proof-Series-Part-2/
Interesting release in terms of price, color & age. Less pronounced than expected, in a good way. Slightly spicy, lots of cocoa & a bit oily. Considering the age, ABV & color, an unexpectedly balanced whisky, especially for the price!
92, 93, 94 points… wow, just wow! It really has to be ambrosia, this material… and for about 45 euros. Then of course you have to start hoarding immediately and be incredibly philanthropic and resell this ambrosia for just twice the price. You would actually have to laugh if it weren't so sad. The issue price was decent and absolutely fine for the quality offered.
нос 82 · вкус 83 · финиш 81
Too simple and woody
| Нос |
85 |
Alcohol, dark chocolate, wood, nutty |
| Вкус |
84 |
Bitterness and sweetness, chocolate and burnt wood, not so balanced |
| Финиш |
85 |
Not that short, dry wood and chocolate |
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 86
| Нос |
87 |
Very dark sherry notes, coffee, sawdust, sour cherries, caramel. Very pleasant to me, but not overly complex. |
| Вкус |
85 |
Quite woody, spicy (quite an alcohol kick), lacquered wood, dark chocolate. Not very balanced, nose was definitely better. |
| Финиш |
84 |
Minty, dry, woody, bitter, not very long (low to medium length) |
нос 87 · вкус 83 · финиш 85
No notes yet dry January :(...but Can't go wrong for 44 EUR - quite cheap for this Kind of bottle in 2010..oh wait: It's 2024 and Signatory doesn't care - thanks a lot...curious and exited for the moment of truth when opened. I guess the polish friends are now balanced with over and underrating the bottle.. :) I think it's a good easy3 sherry cask plv superb...I like it reduced 1-2 TSp of water... With water: Super fruit I git mon cherries , strawberry, lather / old wood, orange With cinnamon, raisins, darker honey..87 T: delivers the nose perfect quite good on berries, honey, wood spice, a little tickling almost like rose champagne, pepper, darker choclate 90 F: Long With pepper dark choclate , ..87
For my taste, it is much better with a little water than on its own. Price-performance currently top. The sherry is unfortunately a bit too dominant, but still a good single malt. Thumbs up!!!
нос 88 · вкус 84 · финиш 85
Too much barrel. Very sweet, lots of wood, hardly any taste of the actual distillate. The alcohol is very present.
нос 86 · вкус 87 · финиш 87
| Нос |
86 |
Dark fruits, leather, balsamic reduction, figs, candied ginger, brown sugar, toffee cake. |
| Вкус |
85 |
Pipe tobacco, cinnamon, forest berry jam, brown sugar, black coffee. |
| Финиш |
85 |
Raisins, pipe tobacco, brown sugar, light cardamom, orange oil, filter coffee. |
With the first three 100 proof bottlings in this new series, Signatory has definitely brought great whiskys to the market for connoisseurs who have a wonderful PLV! Sovie first after trying the malts for the first time. ...exact notes follow.
Very similar to Batch 9. Just fun.
Quite a charged malt, sweet and spicy, dark fruity and herbal. Unfortunately, the sherry seems slapped on to me, there is little depth. But at 9 years old, where is it supposed to come from? Clearly something for color drinkers. Diluted down to 46% with water, it's too flat, a bit boring and disappears quickly. Still quite tasty and totally ok for 45.00.
| Нос |
82 |
Alcohol noticeable, but well integrated, exaggeratedly clear sherry notes, dark sweet cherries, roasted caramel, nutty spice, lots of herbal notes, a bit of leather mustiness. With water (approx. 46%): much finer, everything is more pleasant, the aroma becomes floral, a little hay |
| Вкус |
83 |
Somewhat oily texture, alcohol is a little pressing, sweet pickled cherries, lots of herbs and malt again and a few hazelnuts. With water (approx. 46%): It becomes surprisingly flat, less sweet, and the dark cherries become light red. |
| Финиш |
82 |
Medium long, nice and spicy (white pepper, dark chocolate, a touch of nuts), a few roasted aromas and slightly earthy notes, becoming quite dry. With water (approx. 46%): Rather short and still slightly spicy, although there are now a few cloves. |
Very solid Blair Athol in cask strength and the price-performance ratio at the issue price of € 45.00 to € 50.00 is absolutely harmonious. Spicy, chocolaty, slightly nutty and with a great Oloroso Sherry barrel flavor. A really great whisky, would like more of it.
Cocoa bomb...
нос 90 · вкус 89 · финиш 85
Sherry, sherry and sherry! Fatty, buttery and incredibly nutty. In the background there is some acetic acid which is a little disturbing and doesn't harmonize well. It fills the entire mouth with power and reflects the aromas from the nose without the (for me) annoying acidity. Pepper also comes into the flavor profile. The aftertaste is extensively spicy and tingling with a dry, delicate bitterness.
нос 87 · вкус 85 · финиш 86
нос 88 · вкус 88 · финиш 87
The nose is immersed in sherry but not consistently; nevertheless, it still presents a good sherry aroma. On the palate, it starts off woody and sour, then transitions to malty with clear sherry notes. It benefits from a good amount of water since the alcohol is not well integrated. With time, it becomes nutty and spicy. It brings more chocolate at the finish. The only drawback or limitation is the youthfulness of the spirit, which decreases the intensity of the aromas while alcohol always prominent. It needs a little more time in the barrel.
| Нос |
82 |
wet earth, cellar, vegetable, herbal, mineral |
| Вкус |
83 |
vegetables, wet earth, cellar, cherry stones, dryness, a bit of creaminess |
| Финиш |
83 |
mineral, sweet-vegetable, slightly warming, medium-long |
нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 86
The sherry casks “overdid” the whisky a bit for my taste. There's not much left of a Blair Athol in terms of taste. But if you like dark sherry notes (strong coffee, dark chocolate, a little bitter...almost ashy), you will be happy here. But this whisky shows again very nicely that for many buyers the color is the most important thing. The PLV is of course great for the whole series!
Odour: medium bouquet, alcohol present, dark Fruits, menthol, coffee... Taste: sweetish basic tone, charged, woody spice, nutty, peppery, medium. Afterall with a slight bitter chocolate note Color: Terracotta, medium water edge, clear Conclusion: A modern sherry profile that overall offers a little bit of depth and therefore seems slightly artificial/superficial - but it is still fun to drink and the price quoted when it was published was clearly in the bargain range...
Its not bad. Drinks a bit hot for age/abv. Water helps but doesn't really get rid of it fully. Not a lot of distillery character coming through. Lots of cough medicine type Edradour olorosso casks. Dried fruit and milk chocolate. Definitely characterful, and I feel like its a bottle that needs to open up (loose some of the sharp ethanol notes), leaving it in the glass for a couple of hours helps. Becomes more vegetal with dark fruits and dried meats that show up. Very savoury drink.